Can a HIPAA-covered entity share medical records with another such entity without patient consent?

by | Apr 3, 2023 | HIPAA News and Advice

Yes, a HIPAA-covered entity can share medical records with another such entity without patient consent if the sharing is for treatment, payment, or healthcare operations purposes, as outlined in the HIPAA Privacy Rule’s permitted uses and disclosures, and as long as both entities are involved in the patient’s care or have a legitimate need for the information within the scope of their respective roles in the healthcare system. In healthcare information management, the sharing of medical records among HIPAA-covered entities without patient consent must be explained. The HIPAA Privacy Rule provides a regulatory framework for the permissible disclosure of protected health information (PHI) among covered entities. This rule, while emphasizing the importance of patient privacy and control over their health information, also recognizes certain situations where sharing medical records without explicit patient consent is both lawful and necessary. In particular, the circumstances involving treatment, payment, and healthcare operations are important instances where such sharing can occur.

Important ConsiderationsDescription
HIPAA Privacy Rule FrameworkHIPAA Privacy Rule governs the use and disclosure of PHI by covered entities.
Balances patient privacy and necessary sharing for treatment, payment, and healthcare operations.
Permissible Sharing Without ConsentSharing medical records without consent is allowed in specific situations.
Supports patient care, operational efficiency, and regulatory compliance.
Treatment PurposesSharing aids in coordinated care delivery.
Healthcare providers access records for informed decision-making and patient outcomes.
Payment TransactionsSharing is authorized for payment and reimbursement processes.
Supports billing, claims, and accurate reimbursement.
Healthcare OperationsSharing supports admin, legal, and quality improvement activities.
Includes audits, legal proceedings, performance assessments, and quality initiatives.
Minimum Necessary StandardOnly essential information is shared.
Protects patient privacy by limiting disclosure to necessary data.
Security and ConfidentialityStrict security measures for shared records.
HIPAA Security Rule requires ePHI safeguards like encryption, access controls, and audit trails.
Collaboration and InteroperabilitySharing promotes collaboration among healthcare entities.
Enhances patient care coordination and communication.
Legal and Ethical ConsiderationsLegal and ethical adherence despite permissible sharing.
Privacy and patient rights are respected.
Patient Trust and TransparencyMaintaining patient trust is a must.
Transparency in sharing practices and commitment to privacy is important.
Ongoing AdvancementsThe evolving healthcare industry may impact sharing dynamics.
Stay updated with HIPAA regulations and industry trends.
Table: Important Considerations for Allowing HIPAA-Covered Entities to Disclose PHI

The fundamental principle underlying the sharing of medical records without patient consent is the alignment of healthcare providers’ responsibilities with patient-centric care. Collaboration among different entities is necessary to ensure seamless and effective patient management. In the context of treatment, sharing medical records allows for coordinated and informed care delivery. A healthcare provider who is directly involved in the treatment or care of the patient can access relevant medical records from other covered entities to gain insights into the patient’s medical history, diagnoses, medications, and treatment plans. This enables the healthcare provider to make well-informed decisions that align with the patient’s best interests.

The sharing of medical records for payment purposes is important in the healthcare system’s functionality. When patients receive medical services, there is a subsequent need for reimbursement, either from the patient themselves, their insurance provider, or a third-party payer. In this scenario, HIPAA allows for the disclosure of medical records to facilitate accurate billing and claims processing. For instance, a hospital that treated a patient may need to share relevant medical records with a health insurance company to verify the treatment’s necessity and appropriateness for insurance coverage. Such sharing ensures that healthcare providers receive fair compensation for their services while maintaining the efficiency of the payment process.

Healthcare operations involve various administrative, legal, and quality improvement activities that are valuable for the efficient functioning of healthcare entities. Sharing medical records within this context supports functions such as internal audits, regulatory compliance, legal proceedings, and performance assessments. For instance, a healthcare organization might need to share medical records with its legal counsel in response to a legal dispute, where the information contained in the records becomes evidence. Similarly, healthcare entities engaged in continuous quality improvement initiatives need to enhance patient care and safety. The exchange of medical records among entities plays an important role in conducting thorough reviews and analyses to identify areas for improvement, ensuring that patient outcomes remain a priority in healthcare operations. While HIPAA permits the sharing of medical records without patient consent under specific circumstances, the HIPAA Privacy Rule does not impose a blanket authorization for unfettered disclosure. The principle of the “minimum necessary” standard is a fundamental to HIPAA, emphasizing the importance of limiting the disclosure of PHI to the minimum information necessary to achieve the intended purpose. This ensures that only pertinent information is shared, safeguarding patient privacy, reducing the risk of unnecessary exposure of sensitive medical details, and avoiding HIPAA violations.

The shared medical records must be handled with care and compliant with HIPAA standards. The HIPAA Security Rule sets standards for the protection of electronic PHI (ePHI) to mitigate the risks of data breaches and unauthorized access. Entities engaged in the sharing of medical records must employ encryption, access controls, audit trails, and other safeguards to maintain the confidentiality and integrity of the shared information.


The sharing of medical records among HIPAA-covered entities without patient consent is a practice rooted in the principles of patient-centric care, operational efficiency, and collaborative healthcare management. The context of treatment, payment, and healthcare operations distinguishes the scenarios where such sharing is both lawful and necessary. However, this practice is under the HIPAA Privacy Rule, including the “minimum necessary” standard and the imperative to safeguard PHI through stringent security measures. As healthcare continues to advance, the judicious and ethical sharing of medical records remains a valuable part of a well-functioning healthcare ecosystem.

HIPAA Covered Entity Topics

What is the definition of a HIPAA-covered entity?
How does an organization determine if it is a HIPAA-covered entity?
Are all healthcare providers considered HIPAA-covered entities?
What obligations does an entity covered by HIPAA have concerning patient data?
Do insurance companies fall under the category of entities covered by HIPAA?
What is a covered entity under HIPAA?
Who would not be considered a covered entity under HIPAA?
Is an employer a covered entity under HIPAA?
Who should HIPAA complaints be directed to within the covered entity?
What are the penalties for a HIPAA-covered entity that breaches patient confidentiality?
Are health technology companies automatically considered HIPAA-covered entities?
What distinguishes a HIPAA entity from non-covered entities?
Can a HIPAA-covered entity share medical records with another such entity without patient consent?
How often should HIPAA-covered entities review their compliance procedures?
What types of training must employees of an entity covered by HIPAA undergo?
How do entities covered by HIPAA handle data breaches?
What is the role of a privacy officer in a HIPAA-covered entity?
Are dental practices considered HIPAA-covered entities?
Can a patient sue a HIPAA-covered entity for a data breach?
How are HIPAA-covered entities audited for compliance?
What are the reporting obligations of a HIPAA entity in case of data exposure?
How do third-party vendors interact with HIPAA-covered entities?
Can a business associate be considered a HIPAA-covered entity?
How should a HIPAA entity respond to unauthorized access to protected health information?
What security measures must entities covered by HIPAA implement?
Are there exemptions for certain types of entities covered by HIPAA?
How long must a HIPAA-covered entity retain medical records?
What patient rights are recognized by entities covered by HIPAA concerning their personal data?
Are telemedicine platforms typically classified as HIPAA-covered entities?
What distinguishes business associates from HIPAA-covered entities?
How can patients file complaints against a HIPAA entity?
What is the significance of the Notice of Privacy Practices for a HIPAA-covered entity?
How do international medical tourism practices intersect with HIPAA-covered entities?
Are there specific encryption standards that a HIPAA-covered entity must adhere to?
How do federal and state laws regarding patient privacy relate to HIPAA-covered entities?
How do HIPAA-covered entities handle minor patient information?
Are pharmacies and drug stores universally categorized as HIPAA-covered entities?
How can a HIPAA-covered entity ensure compliance when integrating new technologies?
What are the key differences between a HIPAA-covered entity and a HIPAA business associate?
Are research institutions always considered HIPAA-covered entities?
What are the boundaries of marketing activities for an entity covered by HIPAA?
Can cloud service providers be classified as HIPAA-covered entities?
How should a HIPAA entity prepare for an official audit or review?
What documentation is essential for a HIPAA-covered entity’s compliance processes?
How often do regulations impacting HIPAA-covered entities get updated?
Do educational institutions fall under the scope of entities covered by HIPAA?
How do mobile health apps and digital health tools intersect with HIPAA-covered entities?
What is the role of electronic health record systems in a HIPAA-covered entity?
How does the Health Information Exchange (HIE) network impact HIPAA-covered entities?
Are mental health professionals bound by the same rules as other HIPAA-covered entities?
How do mergers and acquisitions impact the status of a HIPAA-covered entity?
Can patients access all their health data held by a HIPAA-covered entity?
Are billing and invoicing data handled differently by entities covered by HIPAA than medical data?
3 Steps To HIPAA Compliance

Step 1 : Download Checklist.

Step 2 : Review Your Business

Step 3 : Get Compliant!

Our HIPAA compliance checklist will outline everything your organization needs to become fully HIPAA compliant. Fill in the form below to download it now.

View our privacy policy