How do federal and state laws regarding patient privacy relate to HIPAA-covered entities?

by | Jul 27, 2023 | HIPAA News and Advice

Federal and state laws concerning patient privacy, including those specific to HIPAA-covered entities, establish a complex framework in which HIPAA acts as a baseline national standard for safeguarding PHI, while state laws can provide additional protections or regulations that are stricter than HIPAA but must not undermine the basic privacy rights and security measures established by HIPAA for entities such as healthcare providers, health plans, and healthcare clearinghouses, requiring covered entities to adhere to the strictest applicable law to ensure patient privacy and data security.

HIPAA FrameworkThe HIPAA establishes a framework for protecting patient privacy and securing their health information within the healthcare system.
Covered EntitiesHIPAA applies to a range of healthcare entities known as covered entities, including healthcare providers, health plans, and healthcare clearinghouses.
Minimum StandardsHIPAA sets baseline national standards for the privacy and security of PHI that covered entities must adhere to.
State LawsState laws play an important role in patient privacy by providing additional protections or regulations that can be stricter than HIPAA.
Stricter LawsSome states have enacted laws that are more protective of patient privacy than HIPAA, often referred to as “stricter” or “more stringent” laws.
Dual ComplianceCovered entities must adopt both federal HIPAA regulations and any relevant state laws to ensure compliance with patient privacy requirements.
State AutonomyStates have the authority to address specific regional concerns or emerging privacy issues by enacting laws that cater to their unique healthcare landscapes.
HarmonizationCovered entities must harmonize federal HIPAA requirements with any stricter provisions imposed by state laws to ensure the highest level of patient privacy protection.
ComplexityBoth federal and state laws can create complexities for healthcare professionals, administrators, and legal teams who must stay informed about both sets of regulations.
BalanceThe relationship between federal and state laws strikes a balance between maintaining a consistent national standard (HIPAA) while allowing states to enact laws that align with local healthcare needs.
Data BreachesBoth federal and state laws impact how covered entities respond to data breaches involving patient health information, with state laws like data breach notification laws influencing breach response procedures.
Businesses Beyond HealthcareState laws’ impact is not limited to healthcare entities; businesses outside the healthcare sector that interact with patient health information must also navigate this legal landscape.
Enhanced ProtectionsThe combination of federal HIPAA regulations and potentially stricter state laws creates a legal environment that enhances patient privacy protections, building patient confidence in the healthcare system.
Evolutionary ApproachThe state-federal relations allow for a responsive legal environment that can adapt to evolving privacy challenges and new developments in healthcare.
Complete UnderstandingHealthcare professionals and stakeholders must possess an understanding of both federal and relevant state laws to ensure they maintain the highest standards of patient privacy protection.
Table: Relationship Between Federal and State Laws Concerning HIPAA-covered entities

At the federal level, HIPAA stands to protect patient privacy and the security of their health data. Enacted in 1996, HIPAA introduced reforms to the healthcare industry by setting regulations for maintaining the confidentiality of protected health information (PHI) while facilitating the portability of health insurance coverage for individuals. HIPAA’s Privacy Rule, Security Rule, and Breach Notification Rule collectively establish the parameters within which covered entities must operate to ensure the privacy and security of patients’ PHI. HIPAA-covered entities include healthcare entities, such as healthcare providers, health plans, and healthcare clearinghouses. The regulations impose obligations on these entities to maintain the confidentiality and integrity of patient’s health information. This includes measures such as implementing administrative, technical, and physical safeguards to protect PHI from unauthorized access, ensuring secure electronic communications, conducting risk assessments, and designating a privacy officer to oversee compliance.

The relationship between federal and state laws concerning patient privacy is not a unidimensional one; rather, it constitutes a balance between national standards and state-specific regulations. HIPAA serves as a federal baseline for patient privacy protections, establishing a minimum threshold that covered entities must meet. Yet, states are granted the flexibility to enact laws that are more protective of patient privacy than HIPAA, leading to a patchwork of regulations that can sometimes surpass the federal requirements. This balance acknowledges the varying healthcare needs and preferences across different states while maintaining the basic protections established by HIPAA. States possess the authority to implement their own privacy laws, creating a scenario where covered entities must follow both federal and state regulations to ensure compliance. These state laws are known as “stricter” or “more stringent” laws and include provisions that extend beyond the requirements of HIPAA. However, these state laws must not contradict the basic principles established by HIPAA or impede the efficient functioning of national healthcare systems. In instances where a state law imposes stricter requirements, covered entities are obligated to adhere to the most stringent standard to safeguard patient privacy effectively.

This dual framework can lead to complexities for healthcare professionals, administrators, and legal teams. The challenge lies in harmonizing the varying requirements of state laws while complying with the baseline standards established by HIPAA. Professionals must remain cognizant of both federal and state regulations that apply to their specific jurisdiction and the nature of their practice. An understanding of the relationship between these laws and their implications for patient privacy is necessary. The benefits of this understanding are evident in its potential to provide heightened privacy protections for patients. State laws can address specific regional concerns or privacy issues that are not adequately covered by HIPAA. In instances where state laws offer greater privacy safeguards, patients can have enhanced confidence that their health information is being handled with care and diligence. This approach promotes a responsive legal environment that adapts to evolving privacy challenges in healthcare.

The relationship between HIPAA and state laws is not solely confined to the healthcare sector. Businesses and entities outside the traditional scope of healthcare may also interact with patient health information. State data breach notification laws, for instance, can influence how organizations respond to breaches involving PHI. Businesses operating in multiple states must contend with a web of legal obligations, further emphasizing the importance of comprehending the state-federal laws.


The establishment of federal and state laws concerning patient privacy and the compliance by HIPAA-covered entities show the United States’ commitment to safeguarding patient health information while acknowledging the diverse healthcare sector. HIPAA sets a foundational standard for patient privacy, while states retain the autonomy to enact laws that are more protective of patient information within their jurisdictions. The combination of these federal and state laws creates protections that collectively advance patient privacy rights while maintaining the necessary safeguards articulated by HIPAA. Healthcare professionals and stakeholders must remain attuned to these legal updates, ensuring their practices align with the highest standards of patient privacy protection across both federal and state domains to avoid HIPAA violations.

HIPAA Covered Entity Topics

What is the definition of a HIPAA-covered entity?
How does an organization determine if it is a HIPAA-covered entity?
Are all healthcare providers considered HIPAA-covered entities?
What obligations does an entity covered by HIPAA have concerning patient data?
Do insurance companies fall under the category of entities covered by HIPAA?
What is a covered entity under HIPAA?
Who would not be considered a covered entity under HIPAA?
Is an employer a covered entity under HIPAA?
Who should HIPAA complaints be directed to within the covered entity?
What are the penalties for a HIPAA-covered entity that breaches patient confidentiality?
Are health technology companies automatically considered HIPAA-covered entities?
What distinguishes a HIPAA entity from non-covered entities?
Can a HIPAA-covered entity share medical records with another such entity without patient consent?
How often should HIPAA-covered entities review their compliance procedures?
What types of training must employees of an entity covered by HIPAA undergo?
How do entities covered by HIPAA handle data breaches?
What is the role of a privacy officer in a HIPAA-covered entity?
Are dental practices considered HIPAA-covered entities?
Can a patient sue a HIPAA-covered entity for a data breach?
How are HIPAA-covered entities audited for compliance?
What are the reporting obligations of a HIPAA entity in case of data exposure?
How do third-party vendors interact with HIPAA-covered entities?
Can a business associate be considered a HIPAA-covered entity?
How should a HIPAA entity respond to unauthorized access to protected health information?
What security measures must entities covered by HIPAA implement?
Are there exemptions for certain types of entities covered by HIPAA?
How long must a HIPAA-covered entity retain medical records?
What patient rights are recognized by entities covered by HIPAA concerning their personal data?
Are telemedicine platforms typically classified as HIPAA-covered entities?
What distinguishes business associates from HIPAA-covered entities?
How can patients file complaints against a HIPAA entity?
What is the significance of the Notice of Privacy Practices for a HIPAA-covered entity?
How do international medical tourism practices intersect with HIPAA-covered entities?
Are there specific encryption standards that a HIPAA-covered entity must adhere to?
How do federal and state laws regarding patient privacy relate to HIPAA-covered entities?
How do HIPAA-covered entities handle minor patient information?
Are pharmacies and drug stores universally categorized as HIPAA-covered entities?
How can a HIPAA-covered entity ensure compliance when integrating new technologies?
What are the key differences between a HIPAA-covered entity and a HIPAA business associate?
Are research institutions always considered HIPAA-covered entities?
What are the boundaries of marketing activities for an entity covered by HIPAA?
Can cloud service providers be classified as HIPAA-covered entities?
How should a HIPAA entity prepare for an official audit or review?
What documentation is essential for a HIPAA-covered entity’s compliance processes?
How often do regulations impacting HIPAA-covered entities get updated?
Do educational institutions fall under the scope of entities covered by HIPAA?
How do mobile health apps and digital health tools intersect with HIPAA-covered entities?
What is the role of electronic health record systems in a HIPAA-covered entity?
How does the Health Information Exchange (HIE) network impact HIPAA-covered entities?
Are mental health professionals bound by the same rules as other HIPAA-covered entities?
How do mergers and acquisitions impact the status of a HIPAA-covered entity?
Can patients access all their health data held by a HIPAA-covered entity?
Are billing and invoicing data handled differently by entities covered by HIPAA than medical data?
3 Steps To HIPAA Compliance

Step 1 : Download Checklist.

Step 2 : Review Your Business

Step 3 : Get Compliant!

Our HIPAA compliance checklist will outline everything your organization needs to become fully HIPAA compliant. Fill in the form below to download it now.

View our privacy policy